This novel was very well done. The two separate tales of murder were intertwined so flawlessly. I think this may have been my favorite Three Pines story thus far. I applaud Louise Penny for her ability to bring these characters to life in such a manner as to make them living, breathing personalities. I know the series will someday end as all good things do, but till then, onto the next!

This was my favorite Chief Inspector Gamache novel so far. Great weaving of separate stories and character development, as well as drawing from the last book. The history of Quebec and Champlain was fascinating. I loved the interview with Louise Penny at the end. Cant wait to hear the next episode!

I am enjoying listening to Louise Penny’s serious!

I really and truly enjoy this series. The narrator brings the characters to life. The stories and characters are complex and interesting. The characters are well thought out. The story lines are richly written. These are going to make for some nice winter reads. I look forward to each listening session as much as one would dessert

LOVE this series! Get your tissues out for this one. They just keep getting better!

I have enjoyed everyone of Louise Penny's books. Ralph Cosham breathes such life into the characters that it is easy to make a leap from my reality into the lives of Penny's characters.