John Warwick Montgomery, Dr. Angus Menuge & Dr. Alistair Noble
vs. Dr. Sean Carroll, Fred Edwords, & Dr. Lewis Wolpert

This debate took place on October 2008, sponsored by the Literary and Historical Society of University College Dublin. The proposition being debated was, "That this house finds it irrational to believe in God." Dr. Montgomery and colleagues argued in support of the opposition. The audience of approximately 400 voted to defeat the proposition.