After ten years of living her dream in New York, River Sparks returns to her hometown with a bruised ego and a huge secret — she was fired from her once-thriving career as a fundraiser campaign manager. It was also the life she'd chosen over love. Back in the small town she felt she'd outgrown, everything feels the same, including her disdain for her ex, Easton. It doesn't help that he does the unthinkable by entertaining her arch-nemesis, Teara Mills, after their breakup.

Easton Wild, a successful business owner of a construction company, should have it all, but he doesn't, despite appearances. He had all but given up on love or commitment until River's return, and she is reluctantly pulled into working on the town's annual Christmas fundraiser that he chairs.

Old wounds are opened, and old sparks reignite that both are open to exploring. However, another woman's presence is a constant reminder of what may have been their biggest mistake: giving up on each other.

In the spirit of giving back during the holidays, do they learn that the gift of second chances is worth another time around, or do they realize ten years is ten years too late to fix their broken hearts?