This book had a good start, and all the right elements to get you hooked. However, I couldn't feel the final plot reveal. Also, things just unfolded towards the end and it felt a bit formulaic.

I loved this book!!!, so good and creepy, and mysterious, have been looking for a good book to listen to, and have been having a hard time finding one that really held my attention, and I finally found it, can't wait to explore more books by this author, and the narrators were just as good!!! As a fellow bookworm, I highly recommend, one of the best books I've had the honor of experiencing in a while!!!

Amazing story Amazing book! The book was so good I did not want to quit listening! Even was dreaming about it! Would 100% recommend this book to anyone that loves mystery books! Had you guessing till the very end! usally I can predict an ending but not with this one!

The book was just ok. The storyline was slow at times and though there were a few twists in the story, they were both slightly predictable and less than riveting. I had originally thought I would listen to the whole series but after listening to this (the first book), I think one is enough for me. I don’t think the book was a complete loss- it was good enough to listen and finish it, but not enough to make me continue on with the series.

such a good book, couldn't stop listening

The story is indeed gripping, from the beginning to middle. And the narrator did a good job. However, towards the end, the less i enjoyed the book. I feel like the build up is lacking. Most of all, the main character is dull and unlikeable. And the ending was not exciting.

I listened to the audiobook and was hooked on the premise and lore of the midnight man, i especially loved that they added creepy noises throughout the story to make it more immersing. Unfortunately, this fell flat for me. I was expecting suspense and horror but was bored at multiple points throughout and lacked that attention grabbing vibe. There were multiple story lines through the book that did not connect smoothly or was just confusing. It seemed like things were just added for the shock value. Which I would appreciate if done correctly. One significant draw back was Elsie and Im not sure if it was just the narrator for the audiobook or if its a character herself but the author made the most stereotypical overweight southern woman, I lost interest at that point and tried very hard to finish the book despite that. The ending was also extremely confusing, there was little to no background on the midnight man who was apparently obsessed with Sarah and wanted to die with her....this plot felt like it came out of nowhere. There were points throughout the book that just dragged on and that could have been used to make deeper connections or set up for more suspense. I wish I would have liked this better because the story would be amazing if it was just perfected a little bit.

Awful, couldn't finish it

I enjoy a good thriller/mystery. prompted me to listen to the other books in the series.

a half decent read with some interesting strands to it

Great narrators!

loving her style of writing

Twists and turns a story you will not stop listening to! Great characters and narration is fantastic! Can’t believe number 2 is not on here! Already bought on line!!

I was surprised how much I liked this book. It was a fun twisty, thrilling mystery novel. Kept me guessing and trying to figure out what was going on. Very fun and worth the listen!

I loved most of the book and was glad I couldn’t guess the killer but the ending was so disappointing. It seemed rushed compared to the rest of the book and it felt like I didn’t get enough information to actually care how it ended.

Good spooky story. I didn’t like the way the one American was portrayed

Nice plot twist.

Great book loved every minute of it. Kept me wanting more.