On a frigid night in 2013, a wicked storm was closing in on the Miss Ally, a small fishing boat out of Woods Harbour, Nova Scotia, crewed by five young men. Despite multiple weather warnings, the captain chose to stay offshore to retrieve his gear-a decision that proved fatal. Award-winning journalist Quentin Casey pieces together the crew's backstories, a timeline of the foundering, the investigation that followed, and the heartbreaking aftermath.