Abby Stevens doesn't know what's gotten into her, but getting tangled up nightly with the latest bachelor in Buttermilk Falls has to stop. Sure Brandon Swift's got rock-hard abs and blue eyes to die for, but the Los Angles playboy is not the man for her. To end things between them once and for all, she might need some magical help. Brandon is settling into small-town life thanks to his new bartending gig and the cute redhead sharing his bed. He suspects she might be looking for more than a fling. After a bitter divorce and a few months of playing the field, he might finally be ready too. But when Abby presents Brandon with an enchanted cupcake that reverses his attraction to her, both discover strong feelings they didn't realize they had. Is it too late to reverse the spell?